If you're a person looking for dietary advice to embark on a successful weight management journey, it can be an overwhelming and confusing task to try to navigate all the information that is out there. I am often asked by my patients about the Zone, Atkins, Paleo, South Beach Diet, and many others. The question is, is there a certain...
If you're a person looking for dietary advice to embark on a successful weight management journey, it can be an overwhelming and confusing task to try to navigate all the information that is out there. I am often asked by my patients about the Zone, Atkins, Paleo, South Beach Diet, and many others. The question is, is there a certain type of food, or proportion of protein, carbohydrate, and fat that makes up the magical formula to successful weight loss?
The answer to this question, as summarized in a recent article by Dr Sherry Pagoto in JAMA, is that research does not support that any one diet composition is better than another to result in successful weight loss. As Dr. Pagoto notes,
"The ongoing diet debate exposes the public to mixed messages emanating from various trials that have yielded little but have heavily reinforced a fad diet industry."
What does matter is adherence - in other words, when you start a food plan, can you stick to it in the long term? I don't use the word 'diet' when I'm counselling my patients - I use the words 'permanent lifestyle change'. Don't bother making a change unless it is a change that you can stick to for the rest of your life - doing a certain program for the short term may help you to lose weight, but when you stop the program, what will happen? The reality is that about 95% of people will regain the weight, and then some.
Remember that it's not about dropping weight fast - a plan that results in rapid weight loss is probably quite drastic, and is unlikely to be a permanent lifestyle change. Successful weight management is about gradually losing weight (1-2lb per week) with permanent lifestyle change, and keeping it off by making those changes permanent.
Remember that for someone with obesity, losing 5% of your body weight and keeping it off decreases the risk of developing complications of obesity and prolongs lifespan - the greatest success of all!
